Creamy Homemade Vegan Yogurt Recipe

Jan 3, 2022| By JOI team


Jan 3, 2022| By JOI team

Creamy Homemade Vegan Yogurt Recipe

Almond-Base | Cashew-Base | Creamer-Base | Dairy-Free | Keto | Oat-Powder | Recipe | Sugar-Free | Vegan | Vegetarian | 

Have you been missing yogurt on your plant-based diet? If you're one of the 30 to 50 million Americans who are lactose intolerant or just avoiding dairy for personal reasons, you are probably looking for a delicious yogurt alternative.

vegan yogurt

Why Try Our Homemade Yogurt Recipe?

There is nothing more delicious than creamy yogurt added to a smoothie or mixed into a bowl of crunchy granola.  Bonus: yogurt is good for you because it helps support gut health (think:  good bacteria!).  

Living dairy-free doesn't mean you have to go without your favorite snack.

But, many commercial plant milk yogurts you can buy at the store are

  • too watery,
  • too high in saturated fat (looking at you coconut milk!), or
  • filled with additives, like gums and sugars.

So why not control what your yogurt is made of and make it at home?  Developed to perfection with Cultures for Heath, this step-by-step recipe will make your plant-based yogurt dreams come true!

In less than 30 minutes of prep time, you can get started on your own homemade yogurt.  As Ina Garten would say, "How easy is that?"    
Another reason to try this recipe is because it uses shelf-stable, pantry items.  Using JOI plant milk concentrates to make milk means you never have to run to the store to get going on this weekend cooking project!  It's ready to go on your pantry shelf whenever you need some fresh plant milk.  Keep at hand the other shelf-stable products you need to kick start your fermentation process, and you can make homemade yogurt anytime. 

Plus, by making your own yogurt at home, you are in control of the ingredients you put in.  Not a fan of added sugar, gums and fillers?  Yeah, neither are we.  Using JOI plant milk concentrates with Cultured for Health's probiotic powder can make a yogurt suited to your dietary needs. 

Why is Yogurt Good for You?

Yogurt is a food many cultures have incorporated into their diets over the last 4,000 years.  Perhaps that's because it is rich in nutrients and probiotics. And while goat, sheep, and cow's dairy are the "traditional" kinds of milks used to make yogurt, with current health trends, plant-based yogurt is in high demand.

Our gut health can suffer if we don't supply our digestive system with sufficient and varied prebiotics and probiotics. And our homemade plant-based yogurt recipe is a great way to keep these essential probiotics in your diet.

We used to eat plenty of cultured foods before convenience items made their way to grocery stores. "Cultured" food is that changed from its original state with the help of either vinegar, salt, water, or introducing good bacteria. Kimchi, miso, kombucha, and yogurt are all examples of cultured foods that have undergone a fermentation process.

It is important to include cultured foods daily into your diet to supply your body with the good bacteria it needs to keep a healthy gut. There is ample evidence that shows our gut communicates with our brain through its microbiota, so consuming daily probiotics are good for boosting brain power and keeping our moods stable. You could take probiotic capsules instead, but yogurt is a delicious and easy way to get the benefits! 

JOI Plant Milk Concentrates Are More Sustainable Options

JOI is perfect for those people looking to add more plant-based foods into their lives, and also for those looking to reduce their consumer waste! The reusable glass jar that JOI comes in reduces 85% of packaging waste and up to 96% in if you purchase JOI in the larger pails.  Each jar yields up to 7 quarts of milk.  That's a lot of cartons you're saving from the landfill.

Chew on this:  the main ingredient in store-bought plant milk is water.  That means you're buying a carton of milk that is burning fossil fuels because it's being shipped around the country.  Why not improve your carbon footprint and add the water yourself?

The long shelf life of JOI concentrated milk means you can make as much as you need, when you need it (like when you're craving a bowl of cereal or want to make yogurt)! You won't have to stock up on cartons of store-bought, commercial milks that may spoil before you get around to finishing them.  Food waste, be gone!  

vegan yogurt

The Best Vegan Yogurt Recipe - Here it Is!

Now for the delicious and easy recipe to make your yogurt at home.  Let's get to it.

Prep Time: 30 mins

Cook Time: 8-10 hours

Tools you'll need:

  • small bowl

  • blender

  • saucepan

  • clean glass jars/Mason jars with sealing lids

  • yogurt maker or Instant Pot

  • food thermometer


  • 4 cups JOI milk (instructions below)

  • 2 teaspoons pectin powder (we like Pomona's)

  • 2 teaspoons calcium water (included with Pomona's pectin powder)

  • 1 package Cultures for Health Vegan Yogurt Starter


  1. Make your JOI milk by mixing 4 cups of filtered water and 1/2 cup JOI plant base (your choice of almond or cashew, or a mix of both!) in your blender, 30 seconds on medium-high. Once blended, remove 3 cups of milk and pour into the saucepan to reserve for step 3.

  2. Add pectin to the blender with the reserved one cup of milk. Blend until combined.

  3. Add the calcium water to the saucepan, slowly heating to 140˚F.

  4. Add the blended milk-pectin mixture to the saucepan, and bring the temperature back up to 140˚F.

  5. Remove saucepan from heat and let cool to 110˚F.

  6. Sprinkle the vegan yogurt starter over the milk mixture saucepan, whisking  well. If the mixture is clumpy, re-blend in the blender until smooth.

  7. If using an Instant Pot, cover jar openings with the sealing metal ring lids. Alternatively, if using a yogurt maker, pour into the container and follow the manufacturer's instructions for covering containers.

  8. For Instant Pot, place sealed jars on a trivet and close the lid of the Pot. Press the yogurt button called "Yogt" (or similar) for a 10-hour cycle.

  9. For a yogurt maker, incubate for a minimum of 6-8 hours at 105˚-112˚F. The longer it stays in the machine, the tangier the taste will be.

  10. After the heating time, shake jars and refrigerate for 24 hours to thicken.

How to Enjoy Your Homemade Yogurt

Yogurt cultured at home is made with better ingredients, and it can be customized for the taste you prefer.

Want to make it sweet?  Adding a drizzle of maple syrup or honey or date syrup is a healthy way to sweeten your creamy yogurt!

Try making this Turmeric Cashew Granola and eating it with your homemade yogurt for an easy, nutritious and delicious breakfast.

Or, just top with some fresh fruit!

[[ recipeID=recipe-8kk75s5c1, title=JOI Yogurt ]]

Leave a comment

Related Posts

A Dietitian’s Guide To Eating More Sustainably 

Are you trying to do better for the planet? Lea...

Healthy Eating For Busy People: 10 Tips To Eat Well With Little Time

Are you struggling to eat well because of your busy schedule?  There’s a big misconception that healthy eating requires a lot of time and work, but this is far from the truth. JOI’s in-house registered dietitian has 10 tips to help you eat a healthy diet with little time. 

4 Things That Set JOI Nutbase Apart from Nut Butters—And Make for a Better Nut Milk

Let’s take a look at four things that set JOI nutbases apart from nut butters—and why JOI is better to make, better to drink, and better for you.

Comparing Almond Milk: JOI Almond Nutbase Vs. Grocery Store Brands

You’ve decided to make the switch to plant milk. Whether better health is the goal, the traditional stuff doesn’t really get along with your body, or you just like the taste, it probably hasn’t taken you long to figure out you’ve got a lot more decisions ahead of you to find your plant milk. JOI is here to make that decision a bit easier for you. 

Check Out Our Products

Organic Oat Milk Base


Almond Milk Base


Cashew Milk Base


Hazelnut Creamer Milk Base